ICTs for Development - Concerns and challenges 
For IT led Government

 

   

                                                                                      Er. C.K.Dhar,
                                                                                                     NIC

ABSTRACT: This paper discusses about significant impact made by Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) in different countries as well as concerns and challenges before the nation to use ICTs as cutting edge tool for development. Why ICT has to be used by the Governments to effectively meet growing public demands and bring transparency into governance. It is also attempted to identify key components to be taken care while planning and adopting ICTs in India for development so that leaders and decision makers together can asses’ e-readiness at different layers of administration to determine our readiness to integrate technology into our society and governments.
Information and Communication Technology has made a profound impact in many developed and developing countries. With the arrival of IT in a significant way in India, information, services and products are being delivered are undergoing rapid changes in all sectors including the services being provided by the various government agencies to citizens.
It is observed that conscious uses of ICT, which were targeted to under privileged masses and women, had given encouraging yield to raise their socio-economic conditions in many countries. Countries like United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, Singapore and even some African countries have made remarkable achievements by deploying ICTs  effectively in different sectors – whether to achieve a defined citizen’ charter or  improvement in terms of  cost, procedure, easiness and service delivery time against different services

Hence relationship between Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) and Development is being recognized increasingly in all level and across the country.   

* The Author is currently the State Informatics Officer in National Informatics Centre, Dept. of Information Technology, Govt. of India, Agartala. He is a B.E (Electrical) holder and did a short term course on Micro Electronics from IIT-Kharagpur. He is having 13+ years of IT experience in Conceptualizing, Analyzing, Designing and implementation of ICT applications. He can be contacted at chayan@hub.nic.in

Micro electronics, optical fiber, wireless technology, software, Internet, innovative applications and delivery capability of various content thru’ a single device (due to convergence that taking place in three “product lines”- Broadcasting, Telephony and Internet through wired and wireless media) and the ability of ICT to bring large sections of the population on to the “connected world” visibly offer tremendous opportunities. Emerging digital techniques, high bandwidth communication technology, and state-of-the art software for network functions and services, are the new technology trends evident in the development of electronic communication system – though they are not without “challenges”.

 

Table I

Growth of Internet in India   (Figures in Millions)

Month/Year

Internet Connections

Internet Users

Direct Exchange Lines (DELs)

March 1996

0.05

0.25

11.98

March 1997

0.09

0.45

14.54

March 1998

0.14

0.70

17.80

March 1999

0.28

1.40

21.61

March 2000

0.90

2.80

26.65

March 2001

2.30

7.00

32.71

March 2002*

4.50

13.50

40.53

March 2003*

10.0

30.00

48.40

  * Provisional figures

Table 2

Broadband Penetration Worldwide

 

2000

2004*

CAGR

Internet HH

108

192

15 %

Broadband HH

10

104

79 %

Broadband HH as % of Internet HH

9.5 %

55 %

-

 

Table 3

Global Scenario and India( projections)

 

2000

2004*

Global

India

Global

India

Cable

56 %

65 %

33 %

52 %

DSL

43 %

35 %

60 %

48 %

 

Commer.

Household

Commer.

Household

Commer.

Household

Commer.

Household

 

50 %

50 %

30 %

70 %

70 %

30 %

10 %

90 %

Table 4

Broadband Penetration by Region

 

2000

Subscriber: 14 Million

2004

Subscriber: 132 Million

US

45 %

36 %

Asia Pacific

31 %

27 %

W. Europe

12 %

31 %

RoW

12 %

6 %

  HH   -   Households                                                                  CAGR  -   Compound Annual Growth Rate

DSL -   Digital Subscriber Line                                                Row     -   Rest of the World

  E-Governance in its real sense is the use of information and communication technologies to support good governance. It moves beyond old 'IT in government'. E-Governance could be defined as “Government’s use of technology, particularly web based Internet applications, to enhance the access to and delivery of government information and service to citizens, business partners, employees, other agencies, and government entities”  

In one way or the other, the government agencies are the largest service provider to citizens in India. Off late, indeed governments have started behaving somewhat differently in delivering information and services to citizens as because they are becoming more and more demanding in terms of service quality, transparency, cost, convenience and timely services on 24X7 basis.  Why a person should stand in a long queue for a simple government transaction? They are asking why they should visit multiple times for a service.
So it is observed that accountability, transparency, decentralization, procedure, availability and timeliness etc. from numerous government agencies are the key problem areas in the present governance system.
During last few years, a number of initiatives have been under taken at national and state level in India by deploying ICT tools to arrest above issues including to support decision making, planning, development and providing access to information and services.

Some of the initiatives have already made remarkable impact in the areas of i) Property Registration ii) Registration of Vehicles and Issue of Driving Licenses iii) Land Records iv) Passport v) Courts at different levels  vi) functions relating to Central Excise & Customs vii) Market access to farmers-AGMARKNET viii) Utility Billing- Electricity Energy Bill payment, Property Tax payment, Telephone Bill payment, Road Tax payment etc.  ix) India Image Portal x) Warna project xi) Gyandoot project xii) CICs in North East States including Sikkim and so on.

 

 In addition, a few highly successful IT enabled service delivery mechanism and rapid advances made in ICT fields have opened many other avenues; and influenced to adopt ICT tools in mass scale to effectively address common man’s problems in India. But level of ICT infusion into governmental systems varying among different ministries and state to state in India which has already resulted an alarming digital gap. 
While doing careful impact assessments and identifying success factors of such applications and technologies, do indicate and alert about a range of “critical challenges” which are to be taken care at different levels before prescribing adoption of ICT applications. Otherwise, in view of huge investment and negligible return, may derail all efforts and advances made so far.
So adoption of ICT for development or ICT for masses in India needs careful planning, selection of target people, coverage, selection of technologies, economy of scale, replication or roll-over strategy and provisioning infrastructure (ICT) service providers to host such applications on net at national and state level.
 

Initial funding, facility management cost, human resources, training, re-training, affordability, language interface, illiteracy has already taken centre stage of concerns and challenges while  adopting  ICTs in many states in India.  

Some challenges are already visible and seriously affecting to derive benefit offers by ICTs in India.  At grass root level, non-availability of reliable and affordable connectivity (the last-mile), access to ICT tools, Indian script interface supports and relevant content in local languages are already on the list of challenges. 

Though, there is a great deal of hype and fervor about E-Governance across the country. Indeed, it is very difficult to gain an overall understanding about the road-ahead to achieve even bottom line of e-Governance goals when proper implementation approaches are sporadic, no defined role and responsibility for “project leader” , frequent change in administration and “lack of ownership” of ICT applications etc. resulting serious un-certainty about outcome.

Approaches and solutions needs to be tailored accordingly and adopt a strategy based on an understanding of local needs and conditions. 

E-Governance: Stages - defined by UN
Stage 1- Emerging Web Presence
-static information with FAQ
Stage 2- Enhanced Web Presence-easy downloading, search & email for queries
Stage 3- Interactive Web Presence-acts as a portal with online forms
Stage 4- Transactional Web Presence-complete services but usually departmental
Stage 5- Fully-integrated Web Presence-all services online and integrated

The following are the key components to reach to “un-reached” and derive benefit offers by ICTs:

1) ICT Infrastructure Service Provider and Application Service Provider~ computing capacity, network connectivity, bandwidth, last-mile connectivity, and point of presence (PoP) at national, state and district level to take care Government applications.

2) Affordable access to ICT tools i.e., telephone, computer, access to internet etc~ Kiosk, CICs, IVRs, low cost PCs to reach rural masses.

3) Electronic Security at different layers of ICT application~ protecting ICT investment, knowledge base and critical applications from relentless attacks.

4) Arranging public funding for mass scale computerization and evolving viable business model~ computing facility (for backend processes) for citizen centric applications.

5) Indian Language Interface supports, diversity of languages and Illiteracy~ implementation of Unicode, GUI interface etc.

6) Identifying and digitization of relevant content in local languages including categorization.

  7) Preparing IT skilled workforce and project leaders in Government

  8) Process re-engineering and change management in government as well as integration issues between various   departments.

  9) Careful selection of applications and services (of interest to citizens) keeping in mind the issue of return on investment.

  10) IT architecture ( which are open standards, open source, scalable, extensible, manageable  )

  “Electronic Government: Initiatives are evolving rapidly but they have significant challenges”

            David L. McClure

 

Reference:  

The Working Group Report on “Convergence and E-Governance” by Planning Commission, Govt. of India (November 2001)

  Working Group Report on “IT for Masses” published by MIT, Govt. of India   (May 2000)

  E-Governance: Agenda (Published by Sun Microsystems)